The First House By Avni Doshi Book Review and Critique

The First House By Avni Doshi Book Review and Critique

Book Review and Critique By Harsimran Kaur | Rating: 4/5

Is marriage a gimmick or a monstrosity of injustice?

Isn’t it a layer fold of discretions so ambiguously built, and then to see it tumble, fall because eventually it will because such layer’s overtime becomes distorted not because our mind is incapable but how can we always remain meticulously tied to restraint?

Another question that takes refuge is why marriage has fixed ideas?

Isn’t there an idee fixie of a man taking overtaking, undermining, outstripping a woman as if she were now exposed to an autocratic inclination of a man. How is now stands in front of him? Feebler and more fearful, and then I must say patriarchy has become an apotheosis of anachronistic rectitude.

If marriage were to break, how would the mere idea of divorce impact a woman?

  • Will she start hallucinating that the deceive as guilt, and now she must wander like an eldritch resigning to her destiny?
  • Or I see the rebellious fermented emotions reaching the zenith as if the entire scrimmage is about identity that is now shattered and must be proclaimed, and not just remain as a piteous sentiment.
  • Or many times, I have seen a sentiment grow within myself where I become numb, disoriented. Reprehensibility takes over. I feel enfeebled and above all the idea to live alone is like fluttering of wings bruised with blood.

Avni Doshi’s ‘The First House’ is simple and complex. One day a man walks to his wife to tell her that he wants a divorce. What kind of fear then would entrap a woman whose husband is about to leave her? This very humiliating fear has left the woman in shambles, and all along she has learnt that he was a God or a deity who can never b supplanted, and that she must pay obeisance to the divinely spirit that he has become. She must not bring him close to rage, and if that happens then a woman must relinquish her impropriety, if there has been, to appease him.

So, now if the man who is so close to a Godly spirit decides to leave his woman, what must then a woman feel—insecurity, an imprecation, or she must resign to her destiny? And if all this percolates from the fear to live alone and in retrospect—a life led in subservience or preserved necessity or even a crippling stiffness—is it easy to let go off a man who is about to leave you?

But a man leaving you in silence, is it betrayal? The idea or the intent to cheat in marriage is a bit obfuscated. There are reasons but why such reasons must arise? Or these reasons themselves have no soul but are mere descriptive patterns painted around one’s unsatiety of life? Does a man ever think for a second, for a minute of his betrayal? What about the woman like the narrator in the book, has to lose by this betrayal? Isn’t she losing her characteristic enactment of pleasures & displeasures that were always a part of her distorted married life? Now it is not that life without the man is more attentive, but what arises now is that the dispersion of what once rested peacefully has become an antagonistic truth. So, can I say that cheating in marriage arises from disillusioned apathy?

And then comes pain. This piercing pain; the probability to incur such a pain, the pain of betrayal in marriage, and then to restore such a pain, its malignancy—can it be altered?

The stigma to bear such a pain given by a man, like the pain the narrator experiences is a pain of vulnerability. Can such a pain have a name? Can I address it as a performative pain with a rhythm? Or such a pain is exploitive to transcend the ordinary grasp of life as if life & pain are two different patterns and to be in pain is to not live but then we live and is it then that the pain vanishes?

What the narrator is leading right now, this life after her husband has left her in aberrance, is full of loneliness, and now that she is alone, saddened, living with two daughters; does such a pain has the ability to become power, and if pain is power, if pain is to re-create, I wish to be inflicted with such a pain every day.

‘The First House’ by Avni Doshi speaks the fundamental truths of being a woman—a wife, a mother & a daughter. It’s a hypnotising tale that brings across our shattered realities, and as a woman, we dive into it every now & then with obscurity. The narrator is perhaps oblivious to the acrimonious silence around her, what an indescribable torment has befallen upon her when her husband has left her—isn’t this amount to subliminal perception?

‘Love’ has now transformed into scrutiny and concern has become a disruption. The life now is invaded with doubts—of the past whipped with a scalding pain, lots of it, and now she is provoked. Has the time come that she must tither her conscious to detest what all she agreed to, and now must apprehend the capricious honesty of self that she swallowed, and if now she is ready to create a space for her own sensibilities which for son long remained subjugated; in subterfuge of her husband’s illicit impulses?

Somehow, here, I feel like going a but further, out of context, to touch a topic which is concomitant to a woman’s marital morality.

Why must a woman please? Is she coerced to please, or such amusing, a solitary adventure has hidden agendas?

The wife is seldom seen to show displeasures to her man, and if she does, one sees that the ‘intention’ becomes questionable. Then it is followed by an impending doom that she must scale through with content as if compunction no longer drives choices; the choice to justify, and then she must therefore contrive to please because if she does not, she will always be watched over by sadistic vigilance.

On the flip side, a man must not please because it is not required. Why should he because he rules to cause effrontery to a woman. He should not please because his egomaniacal pursuits have left him deprived of fundamental dimensions of human connection. Doesn’t all this hint at solipsistic possession?

Such an amour-propre is a perversion of human kindness & belonging, and it has been seen in marriages where a man is the authority to one’s own gratification & the woman becomes a contradiction.

Coming back to the book, I would like to evaluate two marriages here. One of the narrators and the other of the narrator’s mother. Considering that a man is bereft visible restraint and is full of necessary ego. The husband of the narrator leaves and that of the mother is fielding the expanse of marriage with a provoked imperiousness. But both these women, as a matter of fact, seem to be intimidated by such rationality and by such intransive precision for plots and machinations that a woman fails to confront not because she lacks the pull but because she spends her remaining time to expound on the mercurial vastness. The man carries this flagrant superiority and calibrates the woman by her recursive intentionality.

It is to be observed that when the husband leaves her, the narrator sits, stands as if it is a task; as if the world has collapsed and the Earth will open & proudly embrace her. She is not a warrior or a feminist who will crack the road with rebellion or pour curses at her husband. She is a woman trying to figure out a life without a man; a life which is now bereft of equilibrium & a life which is no longer about systems, patterns and schedules which now she finds monotonous, disharmonious & an embarrassing fraud.

 I must thereby raise a question here,

  • Has a woman ever lived?
  • Has life insinuated a characteristic anomaly by creating her?

The layers she weaves, every now & then, as a mother, daughter, sister, is she entering into a discreditable monotony? What about the imprudence of a man she is subjected to? One sees how gradually all this levels to a moral perfunctory that she is obsequious to. Why then the world becomes intolerant when she, the woman, eclipses her wounds with an unyielding obstinacy?

‘The First House’ is a bit discomforting, and it is not because it re-establishes the idea of patriarchy through ingenious adventure of a man, his adamancy and his impertinence but because empowerment has missed a crucial note—the dismissal of faith; the faith that a woman steps on relentlessly to keep her marriage afloat.

I, therefore, ask why it requires a series of years in marriage or in any relationship, and why only through the burden of domesticity and the conjuring neglect of the kids by a man—for a woman to establish power?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *